Do you ever feel like you can’t win for losing? I feel this way a lot, and it usually has to do with my oldest son. But it’s not because of anything that he does. It’s because of what’s done on his behalf in school.
As many of you might remember, we made a very difficult decision last year. We decided to remove him from his home school across the street and send him to a different school across town because that school offered a full spectrum of special education services which our home school did not. At almost every IEP meeting we’d had, at some point in the meeting, it was implied that perhaps The Mayor could be more successful in a different placement. And we finally went along with it.
Here’s the good news: His special educator is awesome. He’s been in special ed for over 30 years, doing different types of work within the field. He loves the kids. He’s dedicated to them. He spends almost the entire school day with them, a very unusual situation in our experience. He’s apart from them for only 45 minutes of the day. He even eats lunch with them. I know already that he is fully trustworthy, that he has The Mayor’s best interests at heart, first and foremost. All that said, I was really confused about just one thing. He kept mentioning, in passing and casually, that after a few weeks, we would see if the inclusive classroom was working out. You see, The Mayor spends only a portion of his day in the self-contained class with Mr. W and other kids with special needs. The other portion of the day finds him included in a general education classroom where there is a general ed. teacher and an inclusion teacher. The inclusion teacher is there to facilitate the successful inclusion of students with an IEP. Of course, we want The Mayor to spend some of his day there. Up until now, he’s been in an inclusive class all day long. Which is why I just couldn’t figure out the hints about revisiting the placement. Until tonight.
Tonight was the school’s open house. As I arrived, I was happy to see cars lining the streets and a crowd shuffling through the school. I went straight to Mr. W’s room and, there, had a very pleasant and productive conversation. We talked about The Mayor. We talked about the class. We talked about his experience in special ed. When we had covered everything we needed to cover, I mentioned that I would also like to meet The Mayor’s general ed. and inclusion teachers. Mr. W offered to take me to their classroom.
As we walked through the door, I think it’s fair to say, they both seemed surprised to see us. Whatever the reason for that, my impression was not greatly improved as time progressed. Mr. W introduced the three of us and I waited for the typical teacher introduction to conversation: “Your son is so… We’re so happy to have him… The other kids love him…” Anything. But what I got was silence. After we were introduced, they both just looked back and forth from me to Mr. W, waiting, appearing unsure as to why we might have come into the room. And here’s how it went:
Me: “It seems like we’re off to a bit of a rocky start this year”
Gen Ed and Inclusion: blank stares
Me: “What do you think?”
Gen Ed: “I don’t understand what the question is.”
Me: “Well, it seems that The Mayor has been disruptive in class…”
Gen Ed and inclusion: blank stares
Me: “So what can we do going forward to improve the situation?”
Gen Ed: “Well, I assessed him.”
Me: “You assessed him for…?”
Gen Ed: “Spelling. And he could not complete the assessment, so I don’t know how to place him in a reading group.”
Me: “Can you tell me a little about the assessment?”
Gen Ed: “It’s for spelling.”
Me: “How do you administer the assessment? Do you speak the word, and he replies aloud?”
Gen Ed: “No, he has to spell it.”
Me: “Can he speak it?”
Gen Ed: “He has to write it.”
Inclusion: “We have the sample. It’s just scribbles.”
Me: “Okay. Well, The Mayor can’t write yet.”
Mr. W: (mentions something about the fact that The Mayor can write only his name)
Me: “Can you adapt the assessment for him? Can he type?”
Inclusion: “What did he do at his other school?”
Me: “He was allowed to type.”
Inclusion: “Okay… I guess he could type.”
First and least maddening, if you can believe that, The Mayor has an IEP on file at his school. It is a federally mandated legal document that outlines exactly what kind of adaptations and accommodations he requires in order to receive a “free and appropriate education.” In that document, there is a section entitled “Instructional and Testing Accommodations.” Under that heading, one could easily be apprised of the fact that, by law, The Mayor is entitled to some or all of the following accommodations during testing, depending upon the level of need:
1. Assistance with directions, simplifying, clarifying, written directions to accompany oral directions
2. Large diameter pencil, special pencil or pencil grip
3. Flexible schedule, breaks during tests, multiple test sessions or change in order of subtests
4. Group size
5. Respond by word processor, typewriter or brailler.
Second, and far and away the most infuriating thing I have ever had to face in a public school, I had to tell the INCLUSION TEACHER that when you give a child a spelling test, and he scribbles, he requires accommodations. Bold, capital letters, underlined and in italics are not enough to convey my shock and anger.
Imagine this. You find yourself in classroom full of people in your same major, astrophysics. You are all being tested, at the beginning of a semester, in order to determine which small groups you will be divided into for study. Your professor begins to ask each of you, individually, to convey the principles of your field of study; a task for which you are duly prepared. But suddenly you realize, you are required to respond in Swahili. No ones asks you if you speak Swahili. No one is aware of your previous academic records which reveal that you speak Spanish. The professor comes to you, and begins to quiz you. He asks the first question and waits for your reply. When you say nothing, he simply asks another question. You give an answer in Spanish, which he ignores, and poses another question. You continue this way for the entire duration of the test until you have come to the end, frustrated and unable to demonstrate your accumulated knowledge of astrophysics simply because you do not speak Swahili. Because of this, the professor does not include you in a group. It is presumed that you are unable to learn about astrophysics. And you have failed.
If you knew my son, your heart would be breaking like mine was tonight. The thought of him sitting at a table, confused and frustrated, while a teacher forced him to put something on the paper, even if it was meaningless… I can’t come up with any word other than cruel. That is to say nothing of the fact that this is his first full week in a new school, with new classmates, new teachers and, of course, a new aid. His aid didn’t show up the first day. So he’s had a bunch of different people hanging out with him in the interim. His full-time aid started today. But that’s a whole other story, you know.
It feels like getting punched in the gut over and over and over and over again. And just when you think you’ve been punched for the last time, you stand up and take one square in the jaw. I’m tired of writing about it. I’d like to write about something else. Really, I would.